When Someone Suggested It Would Have Been Better to Let My Daughter Die


My wife, Jessica, and I have been to the hospital more times than we care to consider. All that has come with great cost, but great benefit, too. I’d like to impart something. Not wisdom — I wouldn’t assume that much hubris — but at least experience, and perhaps understanding…

My daughter, Namine, was diagnosed with a life-threatening condition. There are, of course, varying degrees of what classifies as “life-threatening” today. Modern medicine has improved much, even over the course of the six years since Namine was born. But Namine has such an incredibly rare combination of birth defects that doctors predicted that she would not survive.

Of course I can’t tell you, with any great certainly, all you might expect. Birth defects vary between children, and even in the respective support groups we belong to, Namine remains unique. But I can share our experiences, and hope that you might take something from them…

Paul eiche the mighty namine

If your child is diagnosed with a life-threatening condition, you need the hospital’s involvement. You need the doctors’ help. Pure and simple, without it, your child will likely not survive. I know for a fact that Namine would not have.

I am a Christian. I believe in a loving God. I also believe that this loving God, whom I worship and to whom I pray, let my daughter be afflicted with compounding birth defects. In case you’re wondering, to me that’s the opposite of a miracle…

But I also believe in a God that works miracles. People look at Namine and say, “It’s a miracle that she’s survived!” And it’s true, it is a miracle, but not one without human involvement. I believe that God has worked through my daughter’s doctors in order to stabilize her.

You might think that I’m contradicting myself, but hear me out. I believe that doctors — and modern medicine in general — are a great help, a blessing from God, and a miracle, even if they don’t know it.

Doctors often believe they have all the answers. At least, they would have you believe they do. But they don’t, and knowing that is crucial.

When Namine was in utero, Jessica and I attended visit after visit at the hospital. Scan after scan, week after week, they kept finding more things going wrong in Namine’s development. Her legs weren’t growing. She had club feet. Her hips were dislocated. Her jaw was regressed. Her heart wasn’t developing correctly. She had worsening scoliosis. On and on and on, the bad news kept piling up and we were met with despair.

Paul eiche the mighty namine

Then came assurance from the doctors. But this was not assurance of a positive note, but of the opposite — she was going to die. This was not “We, the doctors, believe she might die.” This was absolute, unwavering certainty: if we followed through with the delivery, she simply would not survive.

Several times it was not merely suggested to us, but encouraged: abort. Abort. Abort. Spare her the lifetime, however short, of pain and misery. Even if she did survive, she would be in constant agony. Spare her all of that. Terminate the pregnancy. It would be a mercy, nothing more.

Jessica and I refused. Whatever life we could give her, however short it might be, we would not kill her. We believed that we would love her for as long as God would let us have her.

Paul eiche the mighty namine

Namine did not die. Whatever awful fate her doctors had predicted, it did not come to pass. Whatever miserable existence she was expected to have, she has surpassed it…

A former coworker once said to me, upon hearing of Namine’s birth defects, “It would have been better to let her die.”

At the time, I felt a rage I cannot articulate. But despite his tactless words, it is unfortunately the opinion of many — including doctors at our own hospital. So, in a strange way, I am thankful that he was heedless in shooting off his mouth. It has given me the uncomfortable opportunity to confront this unfortunate viewpoint.

Paul eiche the mighty namine

Namine is severely disadvantaged, that much is certain. She has needed surgery more times than we can count — I’m serious, we really have lost track of the number — three of them alone on her heart. There are difficulties beyond measure, were we to measure them. But we don’t, because while they are there, they do not define us…

We chose the difficult road, the one not recommended, and it is one we love every day.

Paul eiche the mighty namine

This post is a shortened version of one that originally appeared on Eiche Fam.

Want to celebrate the human spirit? Like us on Facebook.

And sign up for what we hope will be your favorite thing to read at night.

TOPICS
JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Related to Not Yet Categorized

21 Words That Perfectly Describe My Daughter With Down Syndrome

In honor of World Down Syndrome Day (March 21, to represent Trisomy 21), I’ve come up with 21 words that describe my daughter, Willow, who happens to have Down syndrome. You might notice these words could apply to anybody. Which just goes to show, Willow might have an extra chromosome, but she’s not that different [...]

How Cerebral Palsy Helped Me Bypass Trying to Fit In

A few weeks ago, my teenage nephews were talking with their mom about the pressure they felt to fit in at school. They felt the way they dressed wasn’t cool enough for their school friends. I immediately thought of my teenage years and how I didn’t feel the pressure to fit in with the other [...]

Why I Can’t Hate Autism

Dear Autism, Although we were formally introduced only three years ago, I have lived with you for seven years. We are intimately involved every day, but I hardly know you. I’m still trying to process how I feel about you. I don’t appreciate your mysterious nature or the havoc you wreak, and I am dismayed [...]

Why I’m Thankful for Parents Who Have Their Children Vaccinated

I learned a million strange lessons in doctors’ offices and hospitals with my daughter, Sammi, in the years that spanned cardiac surgeries, gastroenterology drama and everything else her little body gave her to manage. This mastery I had over her health — the details only I could have described — has never gone away. I’m [...]