The Question I Dread Hearing as Someone With Borderline Personality Disorder


We live in a culture that defines certain phrases, questions or traits as the baseline for politeness and human interaction. Perhaps the most common of these is the question we all ask some version of several times a day: How are you? How’re things? How’s life? It often seems this question is asked more out of a sense of tradition or obligation than genuine care.

When someone asks this question, a mathematical equation to deduce the “right” answer immediately takes place in my head. Can I trust this person with my honesty? Do they really care or are they just making conversation? Will my answer burden them? And the most challenging aspect of this question: How can I possibly respond to this with any measure of accuracy?

The thing about living with borderline personality disorder (BPD) is the inevitable changeability of mood, and with that comes the changeability in my sense of well-being. I could be walking down the beach on a beautiful day and feel a sense of joy. Then a friend might not respond to a text or might respond in a way that comes across to me as uncaring, and I will come apart at the seams. Suddenly my moment of peace becomes a several-hour breakdown filled with uncontrollable crying, a certainty encased in fear I am alone and will die that way. Or, I might have a confrontation with a loved one and find myself overwhelmed with anxiety and paranoia for several hours, then find myself laughing at something when those feelings have passed, or the loved one has reassured me multiple times that they don’t hate me. The much longer lasting ups and downs of bipolar disorder further complicate all of this.

So when someone asks me how I am or how I’ve been doing, even if I am able to conclude that the person asking is genuine, trustworthy and won’t be burdened by my answer, I’m still left with the difficulty of not even knowing how to answer with any clarity. Because the reality is, my day-to-day sense of being is more evasive than dry sand slipping through fingers. And when I attempt to answer by considering how I’ve been over a collective amount of time — be it days, weeks or months — all I can recall is the number of breakdowns I’ve had in the said period of time. Which usually triggers a sense of shame. So I will often find myself saying “OK” because it seems like the only thing to say.

What I have noticed with trusted friends is that more specific questions can be helpful, for example: “How are you right now?” Or, “how are you today?” Being asked about any recent events or struggles the person is aware of is also helpful because it gives me a specific subject to respond to, rather than an overwhelming wave of multiple issues I don’t know how to explain.

I don’t know if others living with BPD and/or bipolar disorder struggle with this question in the same way, but if you know someone with BPD, maybe ask them and see if there’s a way to communicate more effectively with them about how they’re doing.

Image Credits: Kendall Jordan

Image via Murisa Hasanovic


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Borderline Personality Disorder

woman looking up in forest

Having Borderline Personality Disorder Leaves Me Feeling Misunderstood

At the very core of a person with borderline personality disorder (BPD), there is a longing, a yearning, a need to be understood. We are often told we are manipulative, selfish, needy, clingy and that we can never get enough of what we are seeking. It is not manipulation that is our motive. That has [...]
woman in forest area looking down in sadness

10 Misconceptions About Borderline Personality Disorder We're Tired of Hearing

Few disorders and mental illnesses carry the same level of stigma as borderline personality disorder (BPD). Perhaps you’re thinking, “Well, it can’t be that stigmatized, can it?” But when even medical professionals sometimes perpetuate the stigma and allow it to affect their treatment of patients, we know there is a problem that needs to be addressed. [...]
11 Hidden Signs of 'Quiet' Borderline Personality Disorder (4)

11 Hidden Signs of 'Quiet' Borderline Personality Disorder

What is “quiet” borderline personality disorder?  According to Mighty contributor Matthew Gemma Karamozov, it’s all about how it presents. In his piece, “When You Don’t Fit the ‘Classic’ Definition of Borderline Personality Disorder,” he wrote, The perception of borderline personality disorder (BPD) is one who “acts out.” That’s the “classical” definition, but like every disorder, the condition manifests [...]
ariana grande and pete davidson

The Problem With Calling Pete Davidson and Ariana Grande's Engagement 'So Borderline'

On Monday, Us Weekly confirmed rumors that comedian Pete Davidson and singer Ariana Grande are now engaged after a month of dating. Because Davidson has spoken openly about his diagnosis of borderline personality disorder (BPD), both folks with BPD and those without have taken to Twitter to weigh in on “how borderline” this quick engagement is. Ariana Grande [...]