How Generalizing Mental Illnesses Leads to Stigma

The other day I was talking to a member of my organization, the Awareness Network. As usual, the conversation turned to mental illness stigma. The question is, “Why is the stigma around mental illness so much stronger than around most physical illnesses?” This is just a guess, but maybe it’s because unlike physical illnesses, all mental illnesses are thrown into a basket together and painted with a  broad brush. To some, they are virtually indistinguishable from one another.

Think about it. Someone with diabetes isn’t described as a “physically ill person” the same way someone with depression is described as being “mentally ill.” Physical illnesses vary in symptoms, causes and severity and are treated as such. The same cannot be said about mental illnesses. “Mentally ill” people suffer from “mental illness.” What does that even mean?

The truth is that there are over 200 classified mental illnesses. When we group them all together, no one is the better for it. Lack of knowledge and understanding is what leads to stigma. How can we expect someone to understand anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, etc. when they’re all grouped together as being the same thing?

There are plenty of months, weeks, and days dedicated to the awareness of specific kinds of physical illnesses ranging from Sepsis Awareness Month to National Asthma and Allergy Awareness Month? There are almost none dedicated to specific mental illnesses and there are less than 10 focusing on “mental illness awareness.”

Not all people with mental illness are the same and they should not be treated or cared for in the same ways. Someone with cancer is treated differently than someone with kidney stones, because people know the difference. People are educated. The same cannot be said for most mental illnesses and that, I think, is part of what leads to stigma.

Those of us who advocate for people with mental illnesses or live with a mental illness need to speak out and we need to be specific. When talking about an illness, we should name it and explain it. Simply saying “mentally ill” won’t educate or benefit anyone. Hearing the words “depression,” “anxiety,” “bipolar” and “schizophrenia” should evoke different understandings. Just as someone knows and understands the difference between a broken arm and the flu, people should know the difference between OCD and panic disorder. That understanding begins with real, honest, and specific conversations. It’s beyond important — it’s essential to ending stigma.

Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.

Related to Mental Health

45 Messages People With Mental Illness Would Send Their Pre-Diagnosed Selves

When symptoms arrive without explanation, it can be a scary, confusing time for someone with a mental illness. Eventually, for those who do receive a diagnosis, answers slowly unravel. Experiences are given names and words like “treatment,” “medication” and “therapy” might become part of a new normal. And while a diagnosis doesn’t change who you are, it can [...]

To the People Who Use ‘Depressed’ as a Synonym for ‘Sad’

Day in and day out, we use a lot of different expressions, like, “You gave me a heart attack!” Did this person really experience a myocardial infarction? No way, they just got really scared. Or when we say, “Break a leg!” do we really wish for this person to break their bone? Of course not. [...]

When I Had a Panic Attack in the Middle of a Walmart

I was in the back of a Walmart a few years ago, and I was walking around and looking at things before I did my actual grocery shopping. I’ve always liked just walking around to see what I might like to buy later on. On this particular day, it had been raining off and on, [...]

What I Want to Tell Anyone Who Puts Their 'Mental Illness' Label First

When I was in my early 20s — before my diagnosis — I identified as a woman, as a social worker, as an aunt, sister, daughter, wife, liberal, etc. Then, with my original diagnosis of bipolar disorder, my entire view of myself changed. There was a shift inside of me. I had to make mental illness part [...]