Why I'm Glad We Didn't See 'Me Before You' Before My Dad's Car Accident


(Warning: Spoiler alerts ahead!)

When we see suicide in the media, the typical reactions are sadness, tragedy, grief, and feeling a life was taken too soon. We start movements to combat suicide. We discuss issues of mental health. We mourn the losses of those not able to be saved, those who couldn’t be convinced that they were valuable.

Now consider “Me Before You.” Will, a wealthy businessman who was paralyzed in an accident, falls in love with his beautiful, working-class caregiver. The smiles, warmth, and connection are the makings of an epic love story, but Will’s decision that his life is not worth living and subsequent suicide do not elicit the typical reactions.

All of a sudden, it becomes acceptable. Even more dangerously, his “noble” gesture is for Louisa’s benefit. “I don’t want you to miss all the things that someone else can give you,” he says. This perpetuates the misconception that people with disabilities are less valuable humans, incapable of being a partner and living a meaningful life.

This trickles into our social consciousness, deepening negative stereotypes that fuel stigma and marginalization.

In the film, Will is not terminally ill. His disability is not a death sentence, and he could have a very happy life with Louisa if he wanted to. His life isn’t over, it’s just different.

Film and television impact what we believe is normal.

Have you ever felt subjected to or judged based on stereotypes depicted in Hollywood films? There’s a reason there are movements to diversify Hollywood, for there to be representation and inclusion.

When disability appears in mainstream media, we see narratives based on pity, inability, and inadequacy over and over again. They reinforce the myth that living with a disability is a subpar existence. We interpret that myth to mean that if you can’t “fix” the person, they’re better off dead. Over time audiences begin to see it as the “normal” for someone with a disability.

Thankfully we didn’t see this movie before my dad broke his neck in a car accident.

My dad’s rehabilitation hospital exposed us to the potential to live a meaningful life in a wheelchair. Seventeen years later, my dad lives independently and works full-time as an engineer. He’s also a loving and active husband and father.

Would my dad have done me a favor if he ended his life by suicide instead?

My 9-year-old brother was killed in that same car accident. There is a big difference between death and disability. But there are still people who tell me they’d rather be dead than live like my dad.

Unfortunately, not everyone is exposed to what’s possible with a disability like my family was. I envision and work for a day where the norm for disability is someone like my dad or millions of others living well around the world. However, so long as their narratives remain invisible to the public eye and fail to counter the stories of sadness, misery, and suicide, disability will continue to be viewed as a death sentence.

If disability becomes a part of your family’s life, wouldn’t you hope to be exposed to diverse and optimistic options for a happy future? I know many people who would give anything for the support Will had behind him. He was wealthy, had a caring family, a caregiver, a home, and the love of his life, yet even with all that in place, he still chose death.

Rather than accept the myth that people are better off dead, we should address the barriers that make living well with a disability disproportionately difficult.

The world was not made with people with disabilities in mind: buildings are not reliably accessible; antiquated policies complicate access to education and employment; and healthcare bankrupts families who seek essential medical equipment and care. One-in-four 20-year-olds living in the United States today will be disabled by the time they retire and there are currently over 1 billion people with disabilities worldwide. These issues deserve attention.

How many more people will ignore these issues because they believe these lives are not worth living?

In the film, Will tells Louisa: “In your life, it is actually your duty to live it as fully as possible.” They even made #liveboldly the film’s official hashtag. This is great advice and a great mantra, but why does it apply to Louisa and not Will? How can you #liveboldly if you’re already dead?

Check out these seven men and women who live up to the hashtag and pick one to share on your social media channels.

Let’s get attention for the narratives that are unrepresented in mainstream media to redefine what it means to live with a disability. And if you see this movie, just keep this perspective in mind: Life isn’t always easy, but it’s certainly worth living.

If you or someone you know needs help, please visit the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline. You can also reach the Crisis Text Line by texting “START” to 741-741. Head here for a list of crisis centers around the world.

The Crisis Text Line is looking for volunteers! If you’re interesting in becoming a Crisis Counselor, you can learn more information here.

Read more on AbleThrive.

The Mighty is asking the following: Describe a scene or line from a movie, show, or song that’s stuck with you through your experience with disability, disease or mental illness. Check out our Submit a Story page for more about our submission guidelines.


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Uncategorized Disorders

puppy playing in a bucket

Dear Well-Meaning People Who Ask Questions About My Daughter in Front of Her

I love your curiosity and concern. I love you. I love talking about my daughter. She is an extraordinary person. I want to tell you something. She can hear you. Not only can she hear you, she can understand the words you are saying about her. Not only can she hear you and understand the words you [...]
Harambe the gorilla.

The Child in the Gorilla Enclosure Could Have Been Mine

By now I’m sure you’ve seen at least some portion of the video taken during the event at the Cincinnati Zoo this past weekend. A boy climbed into the gorilla enclosure, and zoo staff ultimately shot and killed the gorilla before rescuing the boy. The whole situation is tragic. The video coverage of this incident shook [...]
Melissa and her son Noah on the Slip N' Slide.

When I Decided to Be Fearless at My Special Needs Son’s 'Field Day'

It was “field day” and all the children were going down the Slip N’ Slide, including the special needs classroom. The only child not going down the Slip N’ Slide was mine. He was at the bottom watching everyone slide. In the corner of my eye, I saw him and I saw the look in [...]
Justin Trudeau helps a man in a wheelchair down a flight of stairs.

4 Questions Justin Trudeau's Act of Kindness Should Make Us Ask

In 2014, now-Prime Minister of Canada Justin Trudeau helped a man in a wheelchair down the stairs to the Montreal subway. I originally saw this photo on a page I’m subscribed to on Facebook. It received many admiring comments, such as: “Swoon!” (I agree, Trudeau is very easy on the eyes,)  “This man is such a decent human [...]