Old PETA Campaign Linking Milk to Autism Has People Outraged
An old People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) campaign is making its way around the internet again, almost 10 years after it was originally launched. In 2008, the Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN) fought — and won — to have a PETA billboard taken down that linked drinking milk caused autism. In addition to the billboard, the campaign, titled “Got Autism,” also featured an article on PETA’s website, which still exists to this day.
According to PETA, “Anyone who wants to alleviate the effects of autism should try giving cow’s milk the boot and switch to healthy vegan alternatives instead.” The organization’s claims were based on two incredibly small studies, that looked at 20 and 36 children respectively. Since then, multiple studies have found the evidence linking casein-free (the protein found in milk) and gluten-free diets as a “treatment” for autism to be “limited and weak.”
The campaign appears to be brought back to people’s attention by Jack Monroe, an autistic British food writer who tweeted on Thursday asking the controversial organization to remove Monroe’s recipes from its site.
Hi @peta can you please remove my recipes from your website with immediate effect coz I wrote them with my autism. Thanks. pic.twitter.com/1PhJZSJC8l
— jack monroe ❄ (@BootstrapCook) September 7, 2017
The thing that makes me maddest about that @Peta ‘autism’ campaign is the frowny face. The deliberate negative stereotyping of autistic folk
— jack monroe ❄ (@BootstrapCook) September 7, 2017
The not very subtle undertones of ‘oooh you wouldn’t want an *autistic* child now would you?’
I just can’t even… I just…
— jack monroe ❄ (@BootstrapCook) September 7, 2017
Less than a day following their tweets, PETA removed Monroe’s recipes from its site but has not taken down the original article or issued any comments regarding its campaign. Since then, others have replied on Twitter criticizing PETA and asking them to remove the campaign from its website.
@peta just seen your dairy-autism meme. I appreciate it’s old. Can you take it down from the website and apologise please?
— Alan Smith (@mralanjohnsmith) September 7, 2017
Unless PETA can provide definitive, scientific proof that dairy products have a link to autism, they should shut the fuck up. #autism
— Dave (@Red_68) September 7, 2017
oh peta just discriminate against a whole group of people by saying their autism is sad then blame it on milk when that’s clearly shite >:( https://t.co/HiIokvBtus
— △₥☾◉ (@PsychicCatMom) September 7, 2017
@peta Why are you writing such unscientific and hateful things about autism? Have autists ever done anything to you? What’s the reason?
— Hanna Fridén (@HannaFriden) September 7, 2017
LRT: Autism cannot be caused by dairy products. PeTA tries to fear-monger people out of using dairy with lies, which is disgusting behaviour
— OverkillRabbit (@OverkillRabbit) September 7, 2017
Shame on @peta for weaponising autism against parents for their own political ends. It’s absolutely disgraceful. pic.twitter.com/DNJHBXUS8v
— Phil Merry (@PhilipGMerry) September 7, 2017
I’m autistic and I’m able to cook for myself @peta
Might put some cheese on those tasty burgers, thereby giving myself more autism
???????????????????????? pic.twitter.com/GdgCYD5h6Q
— Jonathan Victory (@victorybyname) September 7, 2017
My professional opinion as a scientist working with dairy and mental jealth on PETA’s claim that dairy causes autism:
Load of cunting wank.
— Ciarán O’Brien (@Sarklor) September 7, 2017
Oh yes Peta, because my autism originated from a glass of milk.
— Ivy (@DrawAsIfItEnds) September 8, 2017
but peta is a horrible company for doing all these things I’ve got quite off topic the main point is it’s fine to have autism it’s just fine
— Dan Clayton (@Wiregoathanger) September 8, 2017
Autism is different but certainly not wrong, and has nothing to do with diet! #ActuallyAutistic and have less wrong with me than peta does!
— Kerry Cakes Lovatt (@kerrycakesl) September 8, 2017
@peta Why reflect on Autism negatively, it is simply Beautiful individuality. And making thier mothers feel bad… Disgusting and wrong. pic.twitter.com/Gjmh2U1Z9n
— Thomas Fenton (@TheOfficialFom) September 8, 2017
Dear @peta Whoever creates your marketing campaigns, please fire them. Autism is not a plague. Far from it. pic.twitter.com/ENwk9SyFPV
— Skully Sully. (@MemeGruntSully) September 8, 2017
The campaign’s resurfacing marks the third time people have protested the nearly decade-old campaign. The campaign made headlines again in 2014, but was not removed despite media attention.
Update: A spokesperson for PETA told The Mighty:
This is an old campaign that is still on our website because we have heard from people who have said it contains helpful information. Many families have found that a dairy-free diet can help children with autism, and since the consumption of dairy products has been linked to asthma, constipation, recurrent ear infections, iron deficiency, anemia, and even cancer, dumping dairy is a healthy choice that everyone can make.
The Mighty reached out to Jack Monroe and has yet to hear back.