What Getting Out of a 'Ketchup Jam' Taught Me About Blindness


I waited in the bustling line at the café, passing an equally long line of fancy pastries. This place was famous for their homemade pastries. My friend was already at a table, with coffee. The pastries all looked different, but with my blurry eyes, it was hard to make out how, much less read the names, and most importantly, the price. I was starving and wanted all of them. But every quarter mattered.

How much can I ask without pissing the barista off, or the other starving, cranky people behind me? I remembered seeing jam on the counter once, when I was messing with their condiments. Brilliant! I could buy a whole baguette for cheap and slather it all with jam! I asked, “Do you guys bake your baguettes too?”

“Yeah, we do!”

“Cool! And could you guys cut the bread long-ways?” I asked, worried she’d get irritated.

“Sure! Do you want it heated up?”

“Why not?” I hadn’t even considered it. Emboldened, I asked, “Is the jam homemade?”

“Yes it is! It’s right there on the counter.” Wow, people in the Bay pay a fortune for fancy toast! And I bet theirs isn’t even homemade! I forked out jam by the tons on one half of the baguette. Bet y’all didn’t know you could make toast out here! Although, what else can you do with jam? I imagined ordering it. And I would like it with extra, extra jam. Just keep it coming. Put it on the card. I’ll let you know when to stop. I moved onto the other half, scooping from a bright red jar. No single jam can satisfy a man of such unwavering indulgence. I splattered bright red jam on the naked baguette. Oh, the carnage!

I was ready to devour when a smell of ketchup filled my nostrils. Why does this jam smell like ketchup? Looking closer, I realized my toast had a sloppy layer of ketchup on it. In case anyone was watching, I played it cool. I tried it. Maybe it’ll be like a big old French fry. It was not. It was just a mouthful of ketchup. My toast feast had been cut tragically in half and the smell of raspberry jam and ketchup was so weird.

I looked for a bussing station or the trash, but no luck. I prayed my friend wouldn’t notice. But as soon as I sat, she asked, “Did you put ketchup on your toast? Is that a thing?”

“Oh… I just thought it was jam.”

“Why don’t you return it?”

“It’s cool,” I said, changing the subject. But I hadn’t even thought of that. Can you even do that? I used to never return things. Somewhere inside, many blind people feel we’re already a huge burden on the service industry, and lucky to have anything. So how could I be so ungrateful and return something? But slowly, I’ve gained the audacity. It started with things that were clearly defective. Sorry, there’s a lot of hair in my burrito. Then, messed up orders. Sorry, I asked for waffles, not pancakes. Each step with new fears of judgy responses. Recently I graduated to returning bed sheets, simply because they weren’t quite the color I had expected. But this was a whole other level.

Excuse me? I put ketchup on your bread. Could I get a new piece? So, you want us to give you a new piece because you put ketchup on it? Yes. Not even people who like ketchup on their bread would want this much ketchup. Or even: I put a gross thing on your delicious bread. Can I have a new piece? …or a Danish? So this is your fault, but we should take responsibility? But in these awful scenarios, I never imagined saying anything about being partially blind. Or saying the ketchup and jam could be more clearly marked. It’s like I subconsciously feel being blind is my fault.

Leaving, I got up to put my plate away. This time, after feverish scanning, I found the bussing station, relieved to no longer be The Ketchup on Toast Guy. “Uh,” my friend said, “you know you just threw that plate in the trash bin.”

“Oops,” I said, embarrassed again, but I left the plate in the trash. That’s the risk you take when you don’t mark your ketchups, jams, and bussing station, isn’t it?

Illustration by Kaitlyn Liang Kraybill-Voth.


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Blindness

Fast food restaurant interior drawing.

Why Fast Food Signs Are My Nemesis as a Person With Optic Atrophy

I dread fast food restaurants. It’s not the mega calorie content of the portions or the artery clogging content of their offerings. It’s not even the hyper sodium and sugar counts on their nutritional explainers. It’s the ubiquitous menus behind the ordering stations that customers are meant to casually peruse while waiting to place their [...]
A woman reading Braille.

3 Observations I've Made as I Feel My Way Through a Sighted World

As most people would suppose, there are many challenges to being visually impaired. What they might find surprising, however, is that for me the biggest hurdle is not what I do or don’t see, but the way others view me. The general public seems to be color blind when it comes to people with visual [...]

The Worst Part of Having Low Vision

A few weeks back, I was introduced to a fellow graduate student experiencing progressive vision loss. We connected in a familiar unfamiliar way: the intimacy of strangers with shared experience. After obligatory icebreaking conversation about our research interests, professional pursuits, and hobbies outside of academia, we dived deep into discussing our experiences of vision loss. [...]
Planet Earth at night.

Finding Our Place in the World With a Disability

I’m not sure when I became comfortable identifying myself as a member of the disability community. My experience comes from the progression of a degenerative eye disease called retinitis pigmentosa (RP). Over the course of a number of years I went through what Elisabeth Kübler-Ross describes as the “five stages of grief,” denial, anger, bargaining, [...]