Outrage Spreads Over High School Special Education Program's Garbage Cleanup


Abigail Taylor, a senior at Franklin High School in Elk Grove, California, is starting a petition after watching the school’s special education students clean up after the mainstream students for the past three years.

In the opinions column of Elk Grove’s local paper, Elk Grove Citizen, Taylor explains the school’s practice of having students with disabilities pick up trash around campus:

Every week, students from the special education class at Franklin High School spend sixth period picking up trash, washing windows, and sorting recyclables. Yet, while they perform these menial tasks, typically-developing students sit in their classes, learning. It begs the question: in our modern world of inclusion and progress, why are students with disabilities still left to clean up after the mess of others?

So far Taylor’s petition has received more than 350 signatures from both parents and students.

Administrators from the school district told the Sacramento Bee the students are not performing the functions of the custodial staff. Instead, the program is meant to teach “soft skills” like how to follow rules, keep to a schedule and accept criticism. However, Taylor finds the program “demeaning” and that it puts down students with disabilities, making them appear “inferior” to their classmates who don’t have to pick up trash or sort the recyclables.

Not everyone is outraged by the program. Responses on Facebook to Taylor’s op-ed have questioned how “demeaning” the program actually is.

We need to teach our youths that every job is important and needs to be done, and regardless of who they are, they are providing a needed service so that helps everyone so do it with pride. Labeling it demeaning is wrong.

My daughter went to Franklin. I asked her about this. She said she completely disagrees with this article. The kids aren’t being made to pick up trash; parents enroll them in the class and sign a consent form. She said nobody she knew on campus viewed them as the special kids who pick up trash, and judging by how the kids acted, they enjoyed the task. My daughter said she would routinely chat with the kids in that class, and they all were happy and liked the class.

According to The Sacramento Bee, a meeting is planned for August to discuss the school’s program.

JOIN THE CONVERSATION

Related to Intellectual Disability

Bernard Tomic

Mother of Model With Down Syndrome Writes Tennis Star Bernard Tomic After He Uses the R-Word

Australian tennis star, Bernard Tomic, is getting heat for an insensitive remark made during a press conference at the Wimbledon Championships. Referring to having to wait for his opponent, Fernando Verdasco, to enter the court, Tomic remarked, “Yeah, I did get to the court prior to him very early, and unfortunately I had to stand [...]
Beer bottles from Special Ed's Brewery

Dear Special Ed's Brewery: You Don't Get It

Dear Special Ed’s Brewery, You don’t get it. Even with your apology and subsequent interviews. You perpetuated stigmas by making intellectual disability something to laugh at. My son is no laughing matter. He was beautiful and smart and loved life. He lived a life without limits, breaking through the limits others put on him and [...]
Beer bottles from Special Ed's Brewery

Special Ed's Brewery Is Drawing Criticism for Its Insensitive Branding

Special Ed’s Brewery in Galt, California is drawing criticism from the disability community for its poor choice of name. The Brewery made waves on social media on Monday for its name as well as its slogan – “Ride the short bus to special beer” – and the names of some of its brews. A photo [...]
Gary Owen and disability advocates

Gary Owen Removes Offensive R-Word Part of His Showtime Comedy Special

Late this past April, Special Olympics Chairman of the Board Tim Shriver released a statement asking Showtime to remove a section of comedian Gary Owen’s comedy special, “Gary Owen: I Agree With Myself.” The special, which originally premiered in January, featured jokes about Owen’s cousin, who has an intellectual disability. In one segment he calls her [...]