Vogue Brazil Photoshops Models to Look Like Paralympic Athletes


Vogue Brazils is facing controversy over its new photo campaign featuring two able-bodied models, Brazilian actors Cleo Pires and Paulo Vilhena, photoshopped as Paralympian athletes Renato Leite and Bruna Alexandre.

Vogue Brazil photoshopped campaign

According to an Instagram caption posted by Vogue Brazil, Pires and Vilhena are ambassadors to Brazil’s Paralympic Committee. They are also the stars of Brazil’s “We Are All Special Olympics” campaign, designed by actors with the support of Brazil’s Paralympic committee and Paralympic athletes. The campaign is meant to bring visibility to the 2016 Summer Paralympics.

The photo posted on Vogue Brazil’s Instagram features a photoshopped photo of Pires without an arm and Vilhena with a prosthetic leg.

“[It’s] hard to understand why Vogue Brazil felt the need to use models who aren’t disabled in a Paralympic photoshoot,” Richard Lane, who works for U.K. nonprofit Scope, told the Huffington Post UK. “There are one billion disabled people in the world. Let’s see disabled people’s lives properly reflected, not imitated.”

People on Twitter aren’t happy either. “Even though there are models with those very disabilities @vogue could’ve featured, they’ve modeled together too,” one person wrote.

Another said: “Wow. That is some grade-A, vomit/rage inducing ableisim right there. NICE GOING VOGUE. ”

Both Leite and Alexandre were in the studios when the photos were shot, taking the time to pose with Pires and Vilhena.

Pires and Vilhena with Paralympian athletes

Despite the controversy, neither Leite nor Alexandre seem to be taking offense to the photos, with both posting the photoshopped image on their Instagrams. On her Instagram post, Alexandre wrote:

Personally, I have been clear that I am so proud to be part of this campaign that the magazine #Vogue began to publish the first pictures of this beautiful work. Our Ambassadors Paralympics Cleo Pires and Paulo Vilhena, helped to intensify and spread the campaign aiming to increase visibility to the Paralympic Movement and gathering the Brazilian fans to be present at the Paralympic Games Rio 2016.

We want to know what you think: Was it wrong for Vogue to photoshop their models? Let us know in the comments below.


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Disability

Tatyana McFadden.

The Biggest Win for Me as a 2016 Paralympic Athlete

In just a few days the 2016 Paralympics will commence in Rio, two weeks after the Olympic Games. And for the first time in history, the Paralympics will be broadcast live on network television in the United States, with over 66 hours of coverage. It will also be the first time that mainstream America will [...]
Screenshot from offensive Bright Side video.

Why I'm Grateful to Be a Person With a Disability

A video recently released by Bright Side epitomized the misconception that being disabled means living in confinement, isolation, and hopelessness. The video showed a series of people wishing for a “better” mode of transportation, such as a bicyclist wishing for a car. It concluded with a clip of a wheelchair user envying a boy walking [...]
Jillian and her son.

Why I'm No Longer On the Sidelines About School Inclusion

It’s a journalist’s job to present the facts, to get both sides of the story and deliver their piece without bias. I haven’t worked as a journalist in three years, yet I realized recently that in some ways I still live like one. Too often, I sit on the sidelines of discussions, taking in the [...]
Businesswoman with a disability interviewing candidate at desk in office.

What I Hope Companies Will Learn From National Disability Employment Awareness Month

Dear Employers, Every October, the United States Department of Labor hosts National Disability Employment Awareness Month, an annual awareness campaign that looks to celebrate and educate about hiring people with disabilities. I’m asking you today to consider supporting this cause, hosting events, and most importantly, looking to employ those with disabilities in your workplace. The [...]