To My Friends Making Dieting Resolutions for 2018


You’re going on a diet, and it makes me sad.

I know, I know. It’s not a diet. It’s eating clean, it’s fitness, it’s a lifestyle change. I’m not here to lecture you on how the diet industry has shifted and changed and morphed to sell you these things instead. I’m not going to ramble on about how capitalism has warped our ideas of progress and perfection. I’m not even going to tell you about the mountains of evidence that people who lose weight through crash dieting almost inevitably gain it back, and about the physical and psychological effects of weight cycling.

I’m not going to tell you any of that.

I’m just going to tell you how sad I am.

I see you posting photos of your body, of your body that is perfect because it is yours, and I see you calling it a “before” photo. I see you asking us, your friends, your Facebook community, to keep you accountable to your goals. I see that insidious feeling creeping into your brain that somehow, you are not enough the way that you are. Not pretty enough, not handsome enough, not strong enough, not thin enough, not loveable enough, not fuckable enough, not enough not enough not enough. And it makes me so, so sad.

Because I’ve been there. I’ve been there over, and over, and over again. Even before I developed an eating disorder that ruled my life for almost a decade, I would poke and prod and push at my body, staring in the mirror and wishing I could just will it into looking differently. I see you walking down that path, dipping your toe into that pool, and it feels like you’re about to dive headfirst in the same piranha-infested waters of self-loathing that took some many years from me. 

And that makes me sad, and frustrated, and tired. It makes me feel like I suffered for nothing, like what I went through meant nothing, because it hasn’t helped me to protect you in the slightest.

Yes, I know not everyone who engages in weight-loss oriented eating or exercising will develop an eating disorder. I know that. And I hope, more than anything, that you never go through that. But seeing people make weight loss resolutions at New Years feels like I nearly died in a house fire, and yet every January people make posts about how great it is to disable your smoke alarms and leave a bunch of candles unattended.

If you or someone you know has an eating disorder, call the National Eating Disorders Association helpline: 800-931-2237.

If I’m being honest, and I want to be honest with you, it also makes me sad because I’m chubby. I’ve always been chubby. Even when I was desperately, desperately sick, I was chubby. And it’s that chubby body, that body that I’m working so hard to love, it’s that same body that you are so eager to change and fix and leave behind.

And I know you don’t mean for me to take that personally, but it’s hard not to — even now, years into recovery from my eating disorder, there’s that voice in my head that says, “Because they’re unsatisfied with how they look, you should be unsatisfied with how you look too.” But as much as I am tempted to follow that thought right down the rabbit hole, I know I can’t afford to budge even an inch. 

At the end of the day, you and I both know you’re going to do what you want to do. And I want to support you in that; I want to support you all ways and always. But I see you laying the plans to wage a war on yourself, and I don’t know how to support you in that.

So in lieu of my support, there are some things I want you to know. 

I want you to know that regardless of whether you “succeed” in your weight loss, I think of you as a success. I want you to know that your body is just one tiny part of who you are — a whole, unique, dynamic, interesting, worthy person. I want you to know that a before and after photo can’t possibly capture the changes in the size of your brain or your heart or your soul over the next year.

And I want you to know I will be here to tell you these things any time you need to hear them.

If you or someone you know is struggling with an eating disorder, you can call the National Eating Disorders Association Helpline at 1-800-931-2237.

We want to hear your story. Become a Mighty contributor here.

Getty image via champja


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Eating Disorders

Woman with confetti falling down

Why a New Year Doesn't Have to Mean a New You

Seven years ago I rang in 2011 in treatment at the Carolina House. The staff did the best they could to make the evening festive, but there was no disguising the feelings that accompanied spending New Year’s Eve in treatment. I felt there was nothing to celebrate about 2010. The only thing I was happy about [...]
A large family are all helping serve Christmas dinner.

3 Ways I Survive Holiday Dinners in Eating Disorder Recovery

The holidays can be trying times for those who have a difficult relationship with food. It seems as though family, friends and work gatherings are centered more around what is on our plates and less around what is in our hearts. Company parties and family dinners can be riddled with anxiety-provoking scenarios, especially for those [...]
friends on the couch

The 'Friends'-Themed New Year's Resolution I'm Making Instead of Trying a Diet or Detox

It was only December 2 when I first heard someone mention his January diet detox plans. In fact, if I think about it, I heard it back in August when someone spoke of her winter diet in 2017 vs. her new diet in January 2018 to plan for a summer trip to Ibiza in 2018, [...]
Sadness, Depression - Sadness, Women, Grief, Anxiety, Hopelessness, Unhappy, Females

My Disordered Eating During the Holidays, as Told By 'A Christmas Carol'

Around Christmastime, I have noticed struggles with disordered eating tendencies have a strange similarity to the famous Christmas story, “A Christmas Carol” by Charles Dickens. Ebenezer Scrooge – a grumpy, lonely and stingy being, is once again alone on Christmas eve, and although I have been fortunate enough to never be alone at Christmas, eating [...]