The Question We Need to Be Asking Before We Blame 'Mental Health' for Mass Shootings

In the wake of any man-made tragedy, we find ourselves searching for answers. How did this happen? Why? Who could have done such a thing? How do we prevent it from happening again? We begin to dig through the perpetrator’s life in the hopes of finding an answer, some piece of irrefutable truth that will help us wrap our minds around this tragedy.

Often times a person’s “mental health” is brought forward and examined. Following tragedies where firearms are involved, I usually see people stating they’d like to see tighter background checks, including some sort of mental health history or exam. And I have to say, I find this very troubling.

Mental health problems are widely prevalent in our country. The phrase “mental health” covers a wide variety of issues, including depression, anxiety, grief, schizophrenia, ADHD and personality disorders. Very few mental health disorders make someone more likely to be violent. So when I see sweeping claims regarding mental health I have to stop and ask, “What exactly are you identifying as a problem?”

In America, gun ownership is a constitutional right. So the implication is if you struggle with depression or have ADHD then you are subject to have your societal rights taken away. Now, I don’t think that’s the hypothetical speaker’s intent… but that’s exactly my point. We can’t afford to be flippant or ignorant when discussing conditions that millions of people live with on a daily basis.

Mental health care and acceptance has traditionally been highly stigmatized and, while things are getting better, a great deal of stigma still exists. Many of us are working as professionals, advocates and clients to normalize mental health struggles and create an environment that allows for safe expression and support, but we have a long way to go. Many people are still very reluctant to acknowledge their own mental health difficulties, let alone share them with others or seek treatment. As we work to change the dominant discourse regarding mental health, careless rhetoric regarding the role that mental health may play in a tragedy has the potential to delay or demolish our efforts entirely. A person’s mental health certainly can play a role in their decision to commit tragic acts, but it’s one part of a very complicated narrative. But referring to “mental health” as a whole when we’re discussing one very specific incident that could possibly be tied to a very specific type of mental health problem is, frankly, irresponsible and reckless.

Stop for a minute and imagine how people would regard seeking treatment or publicly sharing their experiences if mental health = dangerous. Or if we set a precedent where your societal rights can be restricted because you’ve had mental health treatment. I encourage you to share your views and work to craft societal policies that reflect your beliefs. But I’m begging you, please be careful and nuanced when discussing “mental health.”

Getty Images Photo via Martin Barraud

Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.

Related to Mental Health

dana loesch

The Problem With the Way NRA Spokeswoman Dana Loesch Addressed Mental Health

I wish I could write some eloquent, meaningful essay about the way that the NRA representative and president of our country have said disparaging things about individuals who struggle with mental health issues.  However, I have been so glued to the news and lacking sleep that this might wind up being one big long ramble [...]
Congress building in front of the American flag

Dear Congress: If Mental Illness Causes Mass Shootings, Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is

For mothers of teenagers like me, news about a school shooting never gets any easier. We experience the same dread, the same despair, the same fear that someone will attack our children’s school. In between mass shootings, we drill our children on what they would do. We check on their social media accounts. We try to [...]
Male psychologist making notes during psychological therapy

Why We Shouldn't View Therapy as a 'Last Resort'

There is a link in many people’s minds that if someone is in therapy, then their life must be in crisis, and they must be on the verge of a breakdown. This is a common and detrimental myth which only fuels the stigma of seeking help when your mental health isn’t on top form. Let me get [...]
black panther movie

What 'Black Panther' Taught Me About My Childhood Trauma

When I was 10, I tried out for the local synchronized swim club, but I didn’t make it, probably because I couldn’t seem to keep my head under water. The coach took my Mum aside and we left. I never tried again. I learned throughout my childhood that if I failed at something, it isn’t [...]