Americans Shouldn't Have to Choose Between Gun Reform and Mental Health Policy


As the mother of a 17-year-old high school junior, it is heartbreaking and terrifying to think about what the students and families in Parkland, Florida experienced on, and since, February 14, 2018. However, by trying to put ourselves in their shoes and by struggling with some of the most difficult challenges before us as a nation, we are honoring those who died as well as those who survived — because their lives are forever changed.

In response to the horrific attack that took 17 lives and shattered a community, we are seeing a raw, focused and sustained expression of pain and outrage that we have rarely seen before. Where this will lead, we can’t yet know. Students are calling for demonstrations, protests and most importantly, action. This is heartening and encouraging because I believe our nation clearly needs to wrestle with our gun laws, the issue of gun safety and the availability of assault weapons in our communities.

My father was a first-generation American who lied about his age to join the Navy after Pearl Harbor because he loved his country. He was also an avid hunter and a proud card-carrying member of the National Rifle Association. I’m certain he would be shocked and dismayed about how the organization that supported his interests as a gun owner is using its heft to influence public safety policy.

But there is another issue we are having trouble discussing in a thoughtful and productive manner: the emotional well-being of those who are in need in our nation. We need to talk openly and honestly about mental health, but not with the “either/or” approach that seems to be reflected in current online and broadcast conversations. I recently heard a political strategist say we really must talk about mental health as part of the solution. I was excited for a moment, until I realized he meant we need to talk about keeping guns out of the hands of people who have “mental issues.”

We do need to discuss the danger of guns in the hands of seriously troubled individuals. But first, we need to acknowledge some basic truths. Most people who experience mental illness are more likely to be the victims of violence than the perpetrators. Also, much of the violence that occurs as a result of unaddressed mental health concerns is self-directed. And, finally, it’s worth noting that the majority of people who use guns to commit acts of violence do not have a mental illness.

Still, our health care system is woefully inadequate in meeting our nation’s mental health needs. The challenge is great, but not insurmountable. Most importantly we must change how we think about, talk about and address emotional pain and suffering — which all families experience at some point. In my opinion, we clearly don’t value mental health the way we do physical health, and we don’t teach our kids how to care for themselves emotionally. As a result, there are massive cultural barriers that prevent people with mental health challenges, and their families, from talking openly about their pain. This makes it extremely difficult for families to get information about what to do and where to go.

In addition, we don’t have enough mental health professionals or substance abuse counselors in our country or our communities. Furthermore, mental health care, as it is currently delivered, is expensive and only available to those who have the adequate means. And, sadly, some of our laws actually prevent us from providing appropriate care to those who are at risk to themselves and others.

The solution is not to do more of what we have done before, rather to think differently about how to deliver mental health education and treatment. We will only succeed when our communities begin to value emotional well-being and invest in care for our most vulnerable citizens. The young man who killed those students and educators in Parkland, Florida wasn’t born a killer. Something went horribly wrong during his young life, and he fell through the cracks of his community — but there are cracks in every community, and we must do better. Funding innovative prevention and early intervention efforts will save lives and money.

The issues we face are challenging, but challenges provide opportunities. We owe it to our children to have these difficult conversations. We owe it to them to put aside our partisan politics, our self-interests and our fears in order to find solutions that protect them. We owe it to them to do all that we can.

If you or someone you know needs help, visit our suicide prevention resources page.

If you need support right now, call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-8255, the Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386 or reach the Crisis Text Line by texting “START” to 741741.

We want to hear your story. Become a Mighty contributor here.

Getty image via BravissimoS


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Mental Health

woman wearing scarves and holding coffee cup

What to Do If You Are an Introvert With a Mental Illness

If you’ve ever wondered if you’re an introvert or extrovert, there are a plethora of articles out there explaining the difference, but sometimes it can still be difficult to really know if you fall into one of those categories. Typically if you’re an introvert, you are more reserved and shy – being a homebody would [...]
young woman lying in bed on social media at night

Why Social Media Is Affecting Your Mental Health

Social media is affecting your mental health. Many people wonder why or how. The irony is, I am writing this about social media to be posted on social media. We have become addicted to social media. Social media is just like chocolate and alcohol; it is great in moderation. On average, teenagers spend nearly nine [...]
Silhouette of woman petting dog.

The Pros and Cons of Having a Psychiatric Service Dog

I have a service dog for psychiatric needs. One of my many needs is for him to alert to my severe anxiety episodes, since I have passed out from them. And he has stopped me from hurting myself in a disassociation spell. But then come the rude comments from people that make me second-guess myself [...]
A woman sits on the concrete stairs in a very depressed mood, lying next to her on the stairs of her backpack.

What It's Really Like to Experience Involuntary Withdrawal From College Because of Mental Illness

This week, I read this article published by Spoon University, and I was deeply moved to write a response. This article from Nikki Daurio, a Harvard student, tackles similar issues with extensive research and thoughtfulness, and is also well worth the read. The former piece discusses the harmful effects on medical, and specifically mental health [...]