Why It's Important to Get a Second Opinion


I was diagnosed with severe asthma in April of 2015. It has turned my life upside down. The drugs I have needed to keep breathing are steroids. I have needed these in large doses and very often.

The unwanted consequences have been serious, too: Type 2 diabetes, chronic kidney disease. But, I am still breathing.

While away on holiday, I became very ill, and after a stint in the hospital, I decided to find a local lung specialist as we plan to spend several months in this location during each summer. This would be a second opinion.

The very first specialist I saw three years ago was extremely dismissive and really hard to communicate with. He was not very happy to have to deal with all of the questions that I had. Perhaps this was arrogance, perhaps he just didn’t feel it was his job. I didn’t want to see him again!

I have a lung specialist where I live for most of the year and see him for about five minutes once a year. He sends me for lung function tests and doesn’t ask me anything much at all, he just tells me to keep doing what I am doing and that I am OK.

I visited this new specialist in February. He asked me lots of questions. I explained that I felt like the bottom of my lungs didn’t work and that the upper tubes felt like sandpaper had rubbed them raw. I couldn’t understand why I kept having attacks, nor why, during a flare-up, it hurt to breathe.

This specialist sent me for a barrage of tests that I had never had before! He discovered the cause of many of my problems. I have a hiatus hernia that is compressing my right lung, it’s bottom lobes don’t work. The reflux acid is actually getting into my lungs. This is why I have the raw feeling. This is why it actually hurts to inhale and exhale! This is why I keep having attacks without being able to identify a trigger! My lungs are constantly being inflamed.

After three years a specialist actually asked enough questions and listened to me. I will still have asthma, but maybe it will be able to be controlled now. I just have to take a fairly strong reflux medication.

I am so glad that I sought a second opinion. I am so grateful to the nurses who were prepared to discuss this with me. I had believed the two other lung specialists and just accepted that this was the way it was for me.

It is terribly important to seek out other opinions. This new lung specialist was young! He was an excellent communicator. He didn’t just make assumptions. I was listened to!

What I have learnt from this is that I must seek answers and get second opinions. No one specialist doctor is infallible, their diagnosis isn’t always correct.

Getty Image by dusanpetkovic


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Asthma

colorful illustration of a person's lungs and organs

How Asthma Changed My Awareness of Modern Medicine

I spent nearly a decade working for pediatric therapists, and because of this I was always surrounded by children. Not once did I ever get the flu! Ear infections? Sure. Strep? Of course. But I’ve always been big on getting my annual vaccine, and I chalked up my “flu free zone” to just that: vaccines rock. I’ve [...]
A picture of a teenage girl in a hospital bed, her face radiating sadness.

The Struggles of Being a Chronically Ill Teenager

I don’t know what is worse: Having a common disease that is chronic, or always having to explain why I carry so many medications. Few people notice that is offensive to say, “But asthma isn’t that bad! Could it be something else?” These aren’t reassuring comments, every month I get told it’s still the same [...]
watercolor painting of person's profile

When Doctors Don't Recognize the More Unusual Symptoms of My Asthma

I have asthma. My asthma is very, very severe. This has been plaguing my every waking moment since July 2014. I had never experienced asthma prior to this.  My children did not have asthma, so everything about asthma was totally new to me. I am now 67 years old. To say that this diagnosis put [...]
Close up of young mother sleeping on bed with her baby. Focus on child

The Realities of Birth and Motherhood With Asthma

This past year I gave birth to our third child. Her birth was a whirlwind; it was beautiful and empowering. But it took a lot of work. Don’t get me wrong, childbirth is hard work… that part was pretty standard. What took extra work was staying oxygenated. With our first birth I did the usual [...]