Please Stop Scapegoating People With Mental Illness After a Mass Shooting


I have a mental illness: depression. Like Americans everywhere, I’m saddened (but not shocked) at the latest shooting in Florida. Once again, gun rights advocates are the pointing the finger at mental illness and holding it primarily responsible for this act of mass murder.

I’ve struggled with depression and anxiety most of my life. However, having a mental illness does not make me a killer and I’m getting tired of being blamed for America’s gun violence epidemic. Yes, mass shooters likely have — or had — mental health problems. But please don’t confuse correlation with causality. If anything, easy access to these weapons of death makes it easier for us to commit acts of violence against ourselves. Gun-inflicted suicide rates outpace any other form of gun violence by huge margins, yet all our discourse seems to focus on “lone wolf” shooters with mental health problems. Why focus exclusively on their state of mind, to the exclusion of everything else? Mass shooters are exclusively male. Why aren’t we blaming an entire gender for the acts of a minuscule few? Mass shooters have a history of committing acts of violence against women. Should we hold women responsible for getting in the way of a violent man’s fist?

I’ve witnessed paranoid behavior in psychiatric hospitals, but I see even more of it on television and on the internet. Arm teachers? Students as paid actors? We can’t even get a universal background through Congress, never mind an assault weapons ban.

If Congress wants to do something about gun violence, I believe we should deal with the prevalence of guns instead of scapegoating people with mental illness. We’re stigmatized enough as it is. And if you really do want to address issues of mental illness in the United States, put your money where your mouth is. Get guns off the street and fully fund mental health care initiatives. We need clinics and care providers, not Glocks and AR-15s.

We want to hear your story. Become a Mighty contributor here.

Getty image via RobertoDavid


Find this story helpful? Share it with someone you care about.


Related to Mental Health

A boy sitting outside of a classroom

What's Missing From the Debate About Stopping the Next School Shooter

I wish you’d stop and be quiet. Just for a minute. I truly understand. We send our babies off to school in the United States of America. It should be a given they don’t get murdered. But here we are. Another 17 innocent souls have been gunned down, slaughtered in hallways that smell of Elmer’s [...]

22 Memes That Might Make You Laugh If Mental Illness Makes You Tired

“I’m tired of medication, therapy and fighting. I’m tired of being tired. I’m tired of having a mental illness. I’m tired of everything.” These are the words of Mighty contributor Brooke Bowie, from her piece, “To the People Who Don’t Understand Why Mental Illness Makes Me so Tired.” If you can relate, you’re not alone. [...]
parkland shooting survivors with senator gabby giffords

Trust Me, I'm a Doctor: Teens Really Will Change the World

As the author of a self-help book for grieving teen siblings, a former undergraduate college department chair, and clinician specializing in adolescent mental health, I’ve been saying it for years: there really is no greater force than an adolescent on a mission. In the wake of the Majory Stoneman Douglas shooting and the March for [...]
Pile of white pills on blue background

I'm Medicated for My Mental Illness — and I’m OK With That

I’ve been medicated long enough to forget the time in my life when I was unmedicated. However, I do remember what it was like when my current medication stopped working. I was sitting in my therapist’s office watching her face as she gave my screening forms the once over. And then she said, “I don’t [...]