The Mighty Logo

Why I Struggle With Giving the 'Supermarket Answer' When Asked How My Child Is Doing

The most helpful emails in health
Browse our free newsletters

How are you doing?

For almost all of us in our daily life, this question has become nearly meaningless. It’s part of an exchange of the most minimal pleasantries. We think of it more akin to saying hello than an actual request for more information. The most expected – if not the only acceptable — reply is “good,” “hanging in there,” or “not bad.” Rarely does the questioner push for much more of an answer.

But with a rare disease the question can shift a bit. Asking about my son, Lucas who lives with Menkes disease, there can be just enough added interest to suggest the answer should have more detail than the minimal “pretty good.” People phrase the question with a bit more intention. “How’s Lucas doing?” means something a bit different than “How are you doing?” and “How has Lucas been?” might carry a bit more weight.

When I’m asked this I have to decide pretty quickly how much of an answer you want. Is one or both of us in too much of a hurry for an answer other than “He’s good.”? A fellow rare disease parent and advocate Jennifer Siedman of Courageous Parents Network calls this the “supermarket answer.” It’s the quick response you might offer when passing an acquaintance in the supermarket. We know we don’t have time to get into a longer more accurate answer. My partner in the Rare Disease Film Festival, Bo Bigelo,w ran with this notion in an episode of his podcast “Stronger Every Day.”

Even when we’re in a stretch of mostly positive health for Lucas, I personally never feel honest using the short hand answer “He’s good.” Should I answer “He’s good, for now.”? It is pretty accurate, but a bit brutal. The shorter answer feels dismissive of their interest, like I don’t want to talk about it and they’ve bothered me by asking. This is almost never the case. I love to talk about Lucas and am always appreciative of others’ concern for him. Also anyone who knows Lucas’ condition finds an unqualified answer of “good” disingenuous. They know he’s not in normal health and the potential for health catastrophes is always looming. What do I mean by “good”? Am I brushing off the question?

So my go-to answer has become just a bit more involved. When Lucas has indeed been healthy for a stretch, I’ll answer “He’s been his version of healthy. Lots of laughs and smiles,” or “He’s surprisingly healthy, we measure that by no unplanned hospital visits in the past two years.” Yep, that exact mouthful. I feel I have to define my terms if I say “good” or “healthy” describing my son. If the friend I’m talking to has learned anything about Menkes disease, they’re aware of how bad things might be. Lucas and boys like him could have seizures, could go blind, could get pneumonia, could die. Do I need to list that none of those things have happened recently? If I don’t do this, do I sound reconciled to our fate or far more comfortable with bad fortune than anyone should be?

Another aspect of the “supermarket answer” is not just how much time you have for my answer, but knowing how much of our reality are you ready to hear about. I don’t want to dump a litany of complaints on you. Some friends probably don’t want a casual conversation that quickly turns to the likelihood of a child (my child) dying in the next few years.

Perhaps it’s best to start out vague and wait to see if there’s a follow up question. “So he’s better?” (No, I can never say a blanket “yes” to that one.) “Any new research on Menkes?” (You’ve opened the door wide with that question my friend. Thank you.)

And it’s no better in the virtual space compared to actual face to face encounters. In our social media world, where often only our best moments get shared with distant friends or family, it can be hard to find the best opportunity to share the other side of life. Of course I’d rather post the pictures of my smiling, laughing boy over one of his pained expressions. And most people would prefer to see the smiling photos. But some people do want to know more of the story. Is it misleading to leave out the rough times? I think it is. Is it a disservice to other families facing
Menkes disease if I make it come off like it’s not a big struggle for our family?

And so you know, as of this writing, we’ve had a very good stretch for Lucas measured by no emergency hospital trips in three years. Last week he did have scheduled “routine” minor surgery that went very well. And yet, even those two sentences of updates feel misleading as I bear in mind most kids with Menkes don’t live to age 10, and my son is more than 9 years old.

So how are we doing?

How much time do you have?

This story originally appeared on

Originally published: April 17, 2018
Want more of The Mighty?
You can find even more stories on our Home page. There, you’ll also find thoughts and questions by our community.
Take Me Home