The Mighty Logo

How to Spot the Difference Between Migraine and Tension Headaches

The most helpful emails in health
Browse our free newsletters

When you’re trying to navigate through your day with a throbbing head, understanding whether you’re experiencing a migraine episode or a tension headache can be more than just an academic distinction — it’s essential to finding relief. Both headache types are prevalent but have distinct characteristics that can impact your treatment choices and quality of life.

Understanding Migraine

Migraine is a neurological condition that can produce a wide range of symptoms and significantly impact your life. These symptoms sometimes include debilitating throbbing pain in the head, along with but not limited to sensitivity to light, sound, and sometimes even movement. There are different subtypes of migraine, and some of them present without headache as the tell-tale symptom.

Symptoms of a Migraine Attack

  • Intense, pulsating headache pain typically on one side of the head
  • Sensitivity to light (photophobia) and sound (phonophobia)
  • Nausea, possibly with vomiting
  • Aura, which can include visual disturbances or other sensory changes before the headache begins

Triggers and Causes of Migraine Attacks

There is no identified cause for migraine yet. You might find that your migraine episodes are triggered by certain factors, which can include:

  • Hormonal changes, especially in women
  • Foods or additives like aged cheeses and MSG
  • Changes in sleep patterns
  • Stress and anxiety
  • Environmental factors such as weather changes

Research suggests genetic factors also play a role, with many people living with migraine having a family history of the condition.

Understanding Tension Headaches

Tension headaches, often described as a tight band around the head, are the most common headache among adults. They are less disabling than migraine and, while uncomfortable, usually don’t keep you from your daily activities.

Symptoms of a Tension Headache

  • A dull, aching pain across the forehead or at the back of the head
  • Tightness or pressure around the forehead or scalp
  • Tender scalp, neck, and shoulder muscles

Triggers and Causes of Tension Headaches

Tension headache triggers can include:

  • Muscle tension in the neck or scalp
  • Poor posture
  • Stress or anxiety
  • Fatigue or overexertion
  • Eye strain

Critical Differences Between Migraine and Tension Headache

Understanding the nuances between migraine and tension headache pain can guide you to better management strategies.

Pain Characteristics: Migraine vs Tension Headache

  • Migraine: The pain is often described as pulsating or throbbing, usually confined to one side of the head.
  • Tension headache: This pain is more often a consistent ache that affects both sides of the head.

Associated Symptoms and Warning Signs

  • Migraine: Aura, nausea, and sensitivity to external stimuli are common.
  • Tension headache: These symptoms are generally not present.

Diagnosis and Treatment Options

Proper diagnosis is critical to treating headache pain effectively. Health care professionals use a combination of medical history, symptom description, and sometimes diagnostic tests to diagnose accurately.

Diagnosing Migraine vs Tension Headache

Differentiating between a migraine episode and a tension headache is crucial for effective treatment, and the diagnosis is primarily based on your description of symptoms, frequency, and duration of the headaches, as well as a thorough medical history and examination. Here’s how health care professionals approach the diagnosis:

Diagnostic criteria

Health care providers use established criteria, like the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD), to diagnose headaches:

  • Migraine criteria: For a diagnosis, you typically need to have experienced at least five episodes lasting four to 72 hours, with at least two of the following: unilateral location, pulsating quality, moderate to severe pain intensity, aggravation by routine physical activity, and at least one associated symptom such as nausea, vomiting, or sensitivity to light and sound.
  • Tension headache criteria: These headaches are often diagnosed based on a history of at least 10 previous headache episodes that last from 30 minutes to seven days and have at least two of the following three characteristics: pressing or tightening quality, mild to moderate intensity, bilateral location, and no more than one associated symptom such as photophobia, phonophobia, or mild nausea.

Monitoring response to treatment

  • Treatment trials: Sometimes, the response to specific medications can help confirm a migraine diagnosis. For example, if triptans, which are specific for migraine, alleviate the headache, it can reinforce the diagnosis.

Some people may experience both migraine and tension headaches, a condition known as mixed headache syndrome. This can complicate the diagnosis and treatment, so it’s essential to have a health care provider evaluate your situation.

Treatment and Management Strategies

For migraine:

  • Triptans: Target migraine symptoms directly.
  • Preventive medications: Beta-blockers, antiepileptics, or antidepressants to reduce attack frequency.
  • CGRP antagonists: A new class aimed at preventing migraine attacks.

For tension headaches:

  • Pain relievers: OTC medications like ibuprofen or acetaminophen.
  • Muscle relaxants: To ease muscle tension for chronic cases.

Treatment plans should be tailored and may combine medication, therapy, and lifestyle adjustments like diet and sleep. Coordination with a health care provider is essential to find the most effective approach.

Preventing Migraine and Tension Headaches

Proactive steps can significantly reduce the frequency and intensity of both migraine episodes and tension headaches. Although each type of headache may have unique triggers, many prevention strategies are universally beneficial. Here’s what you can do to lessen their occurrence:

  • Establish a routine: Bodies thrive on regularity. Sleep, wake up, exercise, and eat at the same time each day to maintain your internal clock.
  • Manage stress: Breathwork, yoga, meditation, mindfulness practice, or cognitive-behavioral therapy can be effective.
  • Regular exercise: Physical activity releases chemicals in your brain that block pain signals. Try to get 30 minutes of low-intensity exercise, like walking, most days of the week.
  • Mindful eating: Maintain a balanced diet and avoid foods known to trigger migraine, such as aged cheeses, processed foods, chocolate, and caffeine, if you are sensitive to them.
  • Stay hydrated: Sip on water every waking hour throughout the day and minimize alcohol and caffeine, which can lead to dehydration.
  • Optimize sleep: Both too little and too much sleep can trigger headaches.
  • Monitor hormones: For women who experience migraine related to menstrual cycles, hormone therapy may help. Discuss this with your doctor.
  • Limit screen time: Excessive time in front of screens can strain your eyes and neck, leading to tension headaches. Take frequent breaks using the 20-20-20 rule: every 20 minutes, look at something 20 feet away for at least 20 seconds.
  • Posture and ergonomics: Correct posture and ergonomic workstations can reduce muscle tension, especially in the neck and upper back, preventing tension headaches.
  • Biofeedback: This technique trains you to control certain physiological processes that can contribute to tension headaches. It is particularly useful in identifying and managing muscle tension.
  • Avoid strong sensory stimuli: Strong smells, bright lights, and loud noises can trigger migraine. Limit exposure when possible.
  • Complementary therapies: Acupuncture, massages, and certain supplements (like magnesium, riboflavin, and Coenzyme Q10) may help prevent migraine episodes.
  • Consult with professionals: A headache specialist can help you identify your triggers and tailor a prevention plan that fits your lifestyle and needs.

Prevention requires patience and persistence. It may take time to notice a reduction in frequency or severity, but incorporating these changes can lead to significant long-term benefits.

When to See a Doctor

Seek medical advice if:

  • Your headache pattern changes or becomes more severe
  • Over-the-counter medications don’t provide relief
  • You experience headaches after activities like weight lifting, sex, or bearing down

Recognizing whether you are experiencing a migraine episode or a tension headache is pivotal for effective treatment. While both can disrupt your life, they require different approaches for management and relief.

FAQ Section

Can tension headaches turn into migraine?

No, tension headaches and migraine are distinct conditions, though someone may experience both at different times.

Are migraine attacks more serious than tension headaches?

Migraine can be more disabling and have a more considerable impact on the quality of life compared to tension headaches, which are generally less severe and shorter in duration. However, persistent tension headaches can also significantly affect well-being.

Getty image by Moyo Studio

Originally published: November 10, 2023
Want more of The Mighty?
You can find even more stories on our Home page. There, you’ll also find thoughts and questions by our community.
Take Me Home